Connect with us

Business

After Monsanto patent ruling, Indian farmers hope for next-gen GM seeds

Editor

Published

on

[ad_1]

MUMBAI/NEW DELHI (Reuters) – A court ruling in India this week that upheld a Monsanto patent on genetically modified (GM) cotton seeds has raised hopes among farmers that the company would now launch its next-generation seeds, the application for which it pulled two years ago.

FILE PHOTO: Monsanto is displayed on a screen where the stock is traded on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York City, U.S. on May 9, 2016. REUTERS/Brendan McDermid/File Photo

India approved Monsanto’s GM cotton seed trait in 2002 and an upgraded variety in 2006, helping transform the country into the world’s top producer and second-largest exporter of the fiber. But newer traits have not been available since the company withdrew an application in 2016 seeking approval for the latest variety due to a royalty dispute with the government and worries over patent claims. (reut.rs/2jbDq80)

Nevertheless, the new herbicide-tolerant variety seeped into Indian farms and many cotton growers openly sowed them last year, prompting a government investigation that is ongoing. Monsanto has said local seed companies have illegally attempted to “incorporate unauthorized and unapproved herbicide-tolerant technologies into their seeds”.

“We don’t understand legal issues but we want new technologies,” Shrikant Kale, a cotton grower in Yavatmal district in the western state of Maharashtra, said by phone. “If the court verdict helps seed companies in bringing new technology, then it would be good for us as well.”

Nearly a dozen other farmers in three Maharashtra districts said they planted the illegal cotton variety in June after buying seeds from the gray market, and that they would be happy to use it legally if Monsanto launched it.

“Illegal sales mean that there’s always a risk of buying spurious seeds and we buy such smuggled seeds as there is no alternative,” said Vijay Niwal, another cotton farmer in Maharashtra.

“We don’t mind paying a few hundred rupees more for seeds if they help us in saving thousands of rupees on managing weeds.”

Monsanto owner Bayer (BAYGn.DE) welcomed the Supreme Court’s decision, saying it “prima facie validates our patent” and that it was confident of “defending any challenge to our patent by presenting solid scientific evidence”.

Asked about plans to launch new products in India, Bayer said in a statement: “Protection of intellectual property encourages innovation that is essential to providing India’s farmers with access to breakthrough technologies”.

But two industry sources aware of the company’s plans said that a dispute over royalties paid by local companies that license its technology remained a hurdle to seeking fresh approval to sell a new variety of cotton seeds. India’s agriculture ministry has twice slashed royalties in the past two years, apart from cutting cotton seed prices.

“The government could step in again to decide the rate of royalty, which could be really miniscule in comparison with the cost of developing a really good product,” said one of the sources, declining to be named as they were not authorized to speak to the media.

“Biotechnology research is very expensive and if the government arbitrarily fixes the rate for expensive, cutting-edge technologies then that becomes a major hurdle in launching new products.”

The agriculture ministry did not respond to an email seeking comment.

“SELF-RELIANCE” GROUP

The court ruling has been criticized by a nationalist group that has links to the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party and favors non-GM technologies and “India first” economic policies. The Swadeshi Jagran Manch, which loosely translates to National Forum for Self-Reliance, said the government needs to amend the country’s patent law to negate the court verdict.

Industry executives say several foreign agrichemical companies had to scale down projects, fire scientists, or pull applications to sell products in India because of government-mandated cuts in royalties and a lower court’s order in April that rejected Monsanto’s patent claim.

They said the Supreme Court verdict overturning the lower court order could set a precedent for any future patent dispute and encourage fresh investments in one of the world’s biggest farm markets, whose seed industry is worth around $3 billion a year.

“The entire biotechnology space has been liberated,” said Ram Kaundinya, director general of the Federation of Seed Industry of India that represents foreign and local seed companies including Monsanto and Syngenta (SYENF.PK).

“There was uncertainty in this area for the last three to four years, which led to a reduction in investments. There are still some issues regarding price control but those are not as big as validity of patents.”

Many biotechnology companies working on corn and other GM crops will now push hard to get government approvals for their seeds, he said, declining to name the companies.

DowDuPont (DWDP.N), which in August last year told the Indian government it was putting off trials needed for approval to sell a GM corn variety, did not respond to a call seeking comment.

A public relations firm for Syngenta directed Reuters to Kaundinya for comment.

But permitting GM food crops is a big call for India, which so far only allows genetically modified cotton seeds.

The country spends tens of billions of dollars in importing food, as dated technologies, poor yields, shrinking farms and unreliable weather patterns afflict the country of 1.3 billion people. But opponents of GM crops say they threaten the country’s biodiversity and are too expensive for Indian farmers.

Annual sales of GM cotton seeds is estimated at $500 million, and Monsanto-developed seeds now control 90 percent of India’s cotton acreage.

($1 = 70.58 rupees)

Reporting by Mayank Bhardwaj and Rajendra Jadhav; Editing by Krishna N. Das and Raju Gopalakrishnan

[ad_2]

Source link

قالب وردپرس

Business

St Laurent Volvo and Land Rover Ottawa: 10 reasons to avoid this dealership

Editor

Published

on

By

St. Laurent Volvo and Land Rover Ottawa dealership have been at the centre of numerous negative reviews by customers. The dealership has left numerous customers dissatisfied with their services due to their sheer unprofessionalism and poor management.

Now, many customers are advising others to steer clear of the dealership either for purchasing or servicing their Volvo—or any other luxury vehicle.

The Volvo brand is known for its high-end services, but the St. Laurent Volvo and Land Rover Ottawa dealership has shown contempt in how it treats customers since their management takeover. Their poor communication, inflated prices, empty promises and late delivery timelines have been the highlight of most customer reviews of the dealership.

“If I had to describe my experience with St Laurent Volvo in one word it would be ‘nightmarish’. The service I received was night and day different from any other Volvo dealership I’ve been to. It is impressively poorly run,” said Sam, a dissatisfied customer who visited the dealership.

Therefore, if you live in Ottawa and need to either buy, service or repair a luxury vehicle, here are some reasons why you should avoid the St Laurent Volvo:

  1. Poor reception

Walking into the dealership alone is enough deterrent as the reception at this dealership is far from top-notch.

Customers who walk into the dealership aren’t greeted to a warm welcome but have to wait endlessly before they can get attended to.

“First I spent 30 mins waiting for a salesman and then left. The second time I spent 15min waiting. During that time, I read these reviews and realized I was making a mistake. Even if I got the car of my dreams it sounds like it comes with the service of my nightmares,” said Rudy Dunno after paying a visit to the dealership.

When customer service representatives are not trained properly, they tend to keep customers waiting for a long time as is the case at St. Laurent Volvo Ottawa.

  1. Inaccessibility

Contacting representatives at St. Laurent Volvo Ottawa is quite very difficult due to how unprofessional their employees are.

Customers have complained about how they have to endure days and even weeks of no communication from the staff at the dealership. This is particularly frustrating for customers especially when they have already paid for the service.

“Receptionist beyond rude… I called to find out the payout of my vehicle and nobody would call me back, had to call 3 times. Never again buying a vehicle from this particular dealership,” said William Delton.

  1. Ignored Better Business Bureau complaint

There is a Better Business Bureau (BBB) complaint filed against the dealership by a customer who had dropped of their Volvo at the dealership early September this year.

However, till date, the BBB complaint has yet to be responded to, showing just how unprofessional the dealership has become.

“It is my humble opinion that this dealership is a shitshow, and I would be highly sceptical about any positive reviews posted based upon our experience which you will see in our very extensive BBB report,” said the claimant.

  1. Dishonesty and failed promises

Making a promising and failing to keep it is one of the major fails in customer service and this dealership is quite notorious for this.

“For weeks they kept promising us they would get the vehicle checked. Cliff and Frank multiple times promised to inspect our vehicle and didn’t,” said the disgruntled BBB claimant whose car was unattended to for almost two months.

Failure to keep promises made to customers is a huge red flag for prospective customers and a sign of irresponsibility.  

  1. Late delivery times

When a problem takes longer than expected to solve, it becomes harmful to the reputation of the business. This dealership can keep a customer’s vehicle unattended to for weeks and without any form of inspection being carried out.

Ramin Mesgarlou expressed his disappointment with the customer service at the dealership after they kept his vehicle for about a year just to fix a suspension fault.

“They kept my truck for about a year to fix a suspension fault. No less than 7 times they said my truck was fixed and it wasn’t .. in fact, the first time it wasn’t even touched,” said Ramin.

  1. Incompetent technicians

There have been numerous online complaints on how technicians at the St. Laurent Volvo dealership fail to diagnose the problem accurately and end up causing more damage to the car.

For instance, Vincent Gradeau had taken his car to the dealership when he noticed some problems with his car’s alternator. After waiting for days to know the status of his car, he eventually called, and they claimed to have fixed the problem, but the car was still problematic.

In fact, Vincent’s car now had a faulty alternator belt— a problem that never existed when he took his car to the dealership.

“The next day comes, they finally call me and tell my car is ready. A few weeks later, my alternator belt started to make a lot of noise. I wait a few weeks hoping the belt will tighten up, but without luck,” said Vincent.

  1. Careless service technicians

Despite how expensive the luxury vehicles that are driven into this dealership are, service technicians are still very careless with how they handle the cars brought in for servicing or repairs.

Guy Lagace took his Land Rover for service only to end up with various scratches and dents that were not originally there when he dropped off his vehicle. Even after insisting the dealership fixed the new damage, they still show a lot of incompetence.

“One week later I again asked to pick up my vehicle and again scratches not repaired but a poor attempt on buffing it, so much it caused more damage (paint burnishing) and left my vehicle full of buffing compound,” said Lagace.

You would expect that your expensive car be handled with care when left and the dealership but that’s not the case with St. Laurent Volvo.

  1. Inflated prices

This dealership gave a quote of almost $3000 to install an after-market Catalytic Convertor that cost less than half that price ($1400) at other similar dealerships.

Failure to keep it fair and transparent with customers is a major reason why you should avoid this dealership.

  1. Suspicious practices

From resisting to issue a formal invoice to racist behaviour towards certain customers, this dealership has been shown to involve in shady practices that shouldn’t be associated with a dealership of its size—or any dealership at all. 

“Then they resisted issuing a formal invoice for contemplated repairs like they are some shady garage,” said a BBB claimant.

The BBB claimant had been requesting for a formal invoice for weeks and when they eventually issued one, they refused to continue with the repairs. Another customer also claims to have been a target of racist behaviour from the staff.

“I have never met such an insolent salesperson who keeps pushing potential customers to other stores. I guess she may have a racist attitude because I reviewed the previous comments,” said Elain Luo, who came to buy a Volvo XC90 at the dealership with her husband.

  1. Poorly managed facility

There is a clear lack of quality standards and accountability from the staff at the St. Laurent Volvo and Land Rover Ottawa dealership. The environment has been made very toxic for customers with rude employees and an unkempt service department.

“Wow, I must say, I saw some poor part department in my life, but this is the worst really. First, it is a dump. It was so messy, just incredible. The gentleman at the counter seems totally lost. In all, I what I am certain is, I will never ever return to this dealership,” said Claude Brunette after a visit to the dealership.

In conclusion, car dealerships always play an important role in the lifespan and ownership experience of your vehicle. Therefore, it is necessary to take your time to evaluate your options and choose a dealership that guarantees you premium services that match and exceed your expectations. 

Continue Reading

Business

St Laurent Volvo: Deeps Dossanjh runs dealership into the ground with Better Business Bureau complaints

Editor

Published

on

By

Once the most popular and revered dealership in Ottawa, the St. Laurent Volvo is struggling to leave a positive impression on customers.

Currently managed by Deeps Dossanjh, the St. Laurent Volvo Ottawa dealership is now riddled with numerous complaints by dissatisfied customers due to their unprofessionalism and sketchy practices. This damage to their reputation by the new management is threatening to run the business into the ground as many customers are now advising others to avoid them either for purchasing or servicing their Volvo—or any other luxury vehicle.

“What has gone wrong at Land Rover Ottawa! When you pay top price for a vehicle you expect a quality customer service and, until recently, that used to be the case,” said Alf, a long time customer of the dealership.

The sheer negligence being shown by Dossanjh becomes clearer in how he has willfully ignored a Better Business Bureau (BBB) complaint filed against the dealership.

“It is my humble opinion that this dealership is a shitshow, and I would be highly sceptical about any positive reviews posted based upon our experience which you will see in our very extensive BBB report,” said the BBB claimant.

According to this claimant, he dropped off his Volvo at the dealership on Sept 1, 2020, for repairs, to later get it repainted before winter. However, for several weeks, he kept getting empty promises on when the vehicle would be checked and eventually got frustrated by the dealership.

Since Dossanjh took over leadership at the St. Laurent Volvo, the quality of service rendered by the dealership has continued to nosedive, said the claimant.

“I have been going to St Laurent Volvo for many years and experienced excellent client services.  But the new franchise owners have no respect for Volvo owners or any clients,” he noted.

The Google review section of the St. Laurent Volvo and Land Rover Ottawa dealership which are both managed by Dossanjh, are filled with various other complaints from disappointed customers. There are various similarities in each customer’s complaints as they border on poor customer service, terrible communication, late delivery timelines and unscrupulous practices.

“Receptionist beyond rude… I called to find out the payout of my vehicle and nobody would call me back, had to call 3 times. Never again buying a vehicle from this particular dealership,” said William Delton in his review of the dealership.

John Avudria, another disappointed customer, spoke of how ineffectual the service department at the dealership when he had issues with his Range Rover Evoque.  

“In 3 months, these guys could not figure a problem that seems to have been with remote key sensors. I had to call Jaguar and Land Rover head office in New Jersey,” said Avudria.

The consistent bad reviews from customers about their poor services shows that Dossanjh is incapable of running this dealership and is bound to run it to the ground if nothing changes soon.

“We just experienced the worse customer service in the history of owning a car!” wrote Victoria Wnek in a review.

Victoria recently moved to Ottawa and needed to get a first-year oil change, fix her rattled speaker and update the software on her Jaguar which was still under warranty. However, after contacting Dossanjh’s dealership, she was met with a series of disappointments—from ignored calls to utter disrespect from the manager.

Eventually, Victoria had to take her car back after several weeks of time wasted going back and forth with the manager who eventually declined to fix the car.

“He wasted our time … and sent us a message that he doesn’t want our business. After being a repeat customer of Jaguar, we are extremely disappointed. These people simply do not care!” she said.

There have also been claims of racism targeted towards certain customers by employees at the Dossanjh’s dealership. 

Elain Luo came to buy a Volvo XC90 at the St. Laurent Volvo dealership with her husband and received a very rude welcome by who she describes as “an insolent salesperson who keeps pushing potential customers to other stores.”

According to Luo, the salesperson may have equally been racist based on her attitude towards her and other Asian customer reviews she had read online.

“I reviewed the previous comments, and another Asian customer also had the worst experience with the same young lady, Alanna Noakes!!! I really felt bad after leaving there,” Luo said. 

St. Laurent Volvo dealership has continued to display unprofessionalism in how they treat their customers and this is a complete deviation from what is expected in luxury dealerships.

“I was left on hold by the receptionist for nearly 15 minutes before finally having the misfortune of speaking to a female on the service department that left me feeling my custom was an inconvenience,” said Alf in his review.

With the amount of negativity ascribed with St. Laurent Volvo, it is only a matter of time before they seize to be operational.

“We are going to ask all Volvo owners who have reported a bad experience online of St Laurent Volvo to collective report to the local Better Business Bureau,” said the BBB claimant.

There’s bound to be more complaints filed against them in the future with the BBB claimant urging more customers to report their bad experiences at the hands of St Laurent Volvo Ottawa.

Continue Reading

Business

Better Business Bureau complaint shows St-Laurent Volvo is getting worse

Editor

Published

on

By

Some businesses assume that most customers would just ignore bad customer service and not care to do anything about it. While that may be true in some instances, more customers today are now telling others about their bad experiences online, especially with the internet being easily accessible to everyone.

In the past few years, St. Laurent Volvo Ottawa has come under heavy criticism by customers over its poor services and now, more customers are sharing their bad experience with the dealership online as a deterrent to others.

Deeps Dossanjh manages the dealership which has now been labelled as one of the worst places to buy or repair a car in Ottawa as the negative reviews that continue mount. Customers expect that a reputable brand like Volvo should have dealerships that provide timely and professional services with staff that are courteous and honest. However, that seems to be the direct opposite of the services offered by St. Laurent Volvo.

“Very bad dealership. Salespeople bad, service desk at this dealership is godawful and I would never EVER buy another Volvo again,” said Dr. Smythe, a disgruntled customer

While reviews can vary from person to person and sometimes aren’t a complete representation of what might have transpired but with Dossanjh’s dealership, the constant complain over their poor services is worth taking a look at.

The negative reviews left by customers at Dossanjn’s dealership are mostly centred around the poor quality of services being rendered and their unprofessional practices. In her review, Steph narrated how she took her few months old Range Rover Evoque to the dealership after noticing a problem with her breaks only to be treated in an unprofessional manner.

“They have to have the worst service for a high-end dealer I have ever experienced. To have to wait 6 months to get them to fix something after I purchased a brand new vehicle is ridiculous,” said Steph after the dealership stalled in fixing her problem.

“We have purchased three very expensive vehicles from this dealer within the last year and will have to look elsewhere when it’s time for a trade. They don’t care about your business after they get your money. Extremely disappointed,” she added.

For a dealership of this size, their services are night and day different from what is expected and there’s even a Better Business Bureau (BBB) complaint filed against the dealership.

“It is my humble opinion that this dealership is a shitshow, and I would be highly sceptical about any positive reviews posted based upon our experience which you will see in our very extensive BBB report,” said the BBB claimant.

The claimant had dropped off his Volvo at the dealership early September this year for repairs and later get it repainted before winter. However, for several weeks, he kept getting empty promises on when the vehicle would be checked, leading to a very frustrating experience.

“For weeks they kept promising us they would get the vehicle checked. They didn’t inspect it until sometime in October,” said the claimant.

In Ramin Mesgarlou’s case, his truck was kept at the dealership for almost a year just to fix a suspension fault.

“They kept my truck for about a year to fix a suspension fault. No less than 7 times they said my truck was fixed and it wasn’t .. in fact, the first time it wasn’t even touched yet they charged my AMEX $3,000,” Ramin revealed.

The decline in the quality of service rendered by St. Laurent Volvo appears to have nosedived since Dossanjh took over leadership, said the claimant.

“I have been going to St Laurent Volvo for many years and experienced excellent client services.  But the new franchise owners have no respect for Volvo owners or any clients,” he noted.

The Google review section of the dealership is filled with other complaints from several angry customers, all with similar complaints on poor customer service, terrible communication, late delivery timelines and shady practices.

“Receptionist beyond rude… I called to find out the payout of my vehicle and nobody would call me back, had to call 3 times. Never again buying a vehicle from this particular dealership,” said William Delton in his review of the dealership.

Another customer, Kelly, equally experienced how staff at the dealership ignored her calls for weeks and never even bothered to return them.

“Called for a service and it went to voicemail and left a message three weeks ago still no callback. They will need to really start working on their customer service skills,” said Kelly.

Dossanjh’s dealership appears to be reaching new heights in bad service with one customer tagging the dealership “the worst customer service in history”. There have also been claims of racism and extortion carried out by employees at Dossanjh’s dealership. 

Elain Luo, who came to buy a Volvo XC90 at the dealership with her husband, said the attendant who welcomed them at the dealership was exhibiting racist tendencies.

“She seemed unwilling to do business with us and I guess she may have a racist attitude because I reviewed the previous comments, and another Asian customer also had the worst experience with the same young lady,” she said.

According to a BBB claimant, the dealership charged him double the rate for the repair and installation of a Catalytic Convertor when similar repairs had been done for a cheaper rate on another Volvo elsewhere.

“St Laurent Volvo was seeking to charge us an inflated price of $2800 for a convertor when I paid $1400 before on a separate vehicle,” said the BBB claimant.

The dealership is still yet to respond to the BBB complaint filed against them and has shown no signs of improving on their services. Now, customers are advising others to steer clear of the dealership either for purchasing or servicing their Volvo—or any other luxury vehicle.

Continue Reading

Chat

Trending